Many Resurrections, Many Rebirths

Easter Multi-Generational Worship Service
April 4, 2010

Reverend Dr. Barbara Coeyman

READING:

“Why Easter” by Marilyn Sewell
(excerpted from Quest: The Church of the Larger Fellowship, Vol LXV, No. 4, April 2010)

"Why do we have Easter anyway? Where does it come from? Well, the simple answer is that the name is derived from the German Eostre, a fertility goddess who was honored with a fertility festival. When the Germanic tribes were Christianized, Eostre merged with the Christian Pesach celebrations. That’s the history. But why do we persist in celebrating Easter? I believe we celebrate Easter because we know we’re in bondage, and we want to be free ...

"Anyone who lives for very long in this world will know what it is to be in bondage, trapped by cultural expectations, or by the past, or just by circumstance. We know what it is to suffer various kinds of deaths: not only the loss of people we love, but the loss of a dream, the loss of a life plan, the loss of certain abilities and options as age creeps up or as we deal with illness or injury. And so we all, whatever our theology, need Easter ...

"I don’t need a corpse rising from the dead to believe in the miracle of Easter.....The real miracle (historically) is what happened to Jesus’ disciples. They were delivered from their preoccupation with self, from their egotistical plans, and gave themselves to Love. That’s the real miracle ...

"I see love doing absolutely amazing things. I see lives changing -- I see it all the time. It comes about, I think, through both intentionality and grace ... it comes when we are willing and when we enter into a partnership with the Holy, and we say, ‘I just want to do some good in this world.’ Intentionality on our part, and grace from the universe, freely given. Jesus came not to do magic tricks and have us worship him as God --- he came to show us that we are all OF God--- and that these miracles of love are possible in our own lives, every day of our lives."

SERMON: “Many Resurrections: Many ReBirths”

This morning millions of people around the world are celebrating Easter. Most people celebrating Easter this morning are followers of Christianity, in its many manifestations. Some recognizing Easter are Unitarian Universalists like us here at Columbine Unitarian Universalist Church. Most Unitarian Universalists, following this liberal faith routed in Judeo-Christian traditions, recognize in some way or other both Easter and Passover at this time of year.

Why do we humans celebrate Easter? There are many answers to that question. In modern times, Easter has usually been identified by the story of the resurrection of Christ from the dead, as recorded in various gospel stories in the Christian Bible. As we just heard in the reading by Marilyn Sewell, one predecessor for Easter started long before the Christian era, when humankind created rituals to honor the re-awakening --- the rebirth --- of the earth. Those springtime celebrations merged nicely with the early Christian need for a festival to explain the crucifixion of Jesus as a vehicle for achieving atonement for all his followers. That is, in sacrificing this one very special human, the sins of all the rest of humanity were therefore forgiven, atoned for. This rendering of the Easter story is the one we hear often in contemporary life, especially here in a region of the country marked by conservative religious culture.

But why do Unitarian Universalists celebrate Easter (and Christmas)? Haven’t we been for centuries heretics of orthodox Christian traditions? Well, one answer is mostly ‘secular’ in reasoning: because much of the rest of American culture in some way recognizes Easter and Christmas as holidays, it’s convenient to join in. Perhaps we’ve been on school break this week, perhaps we think it’s time for a holiday, perhaps we recall the tradition of the ham Easter dinner from our childhoods and want to continue the habit. But there are many other more spiritual ways we can engage in Easter and even consider how a concept like resurrection can apply to us.

Interpretations of the Concept of ‘Resurrection’
I suspect that for many of us the concept of literal ‘resurrection’ may be a hard one to grasp. Dead bodies just don’t rise again, and it’s a stretch to believe that one man dying can save a significant portion of the population of the planet. Personally you may reject all the features of Easter I’ve mentioned thus far, except the ham dinner awaiting you after church.

However, there are explanations for why the orthodox version of the resurrection story evolved as it did, largely political in nature. By the fourth century, when Christianity became the official state religion of the Roman Empire under Constantine, there were certain doctrine one had to accept. The ‘state’ spin on the resurrection story supported the political structure of the church: that is, only those apostles who reportedly had seen the risen Christ directly were considered to be true heirs to his ministry, and thus, the true representatives in the line of succession that created the church hierarchy that is believed to continue on down to the present day in some traditions. That is, there was a need for the presence of a risen body to substantiate this lineage. In this political religious system, those who conformed were among the select, the ones who achieved atonement.

It is important for us to remember that there are many renderings of Christian doctrine, and I call you to consider yet other interpretations of Easter and resurrection. Recall, for example, that our religious ancestors on both sides --- Unitarians and Universalists --- who were by definition Christian until well into the twentieth century, still rejected much of the establishment’s rendering of the Easter story. For instance, Unitarians in the mid-nineteenth century (such as Channing, Emerson and Parker) wrote volumes on divinity as a unity --- unitarian --- making Jesus a ‘regular’ human being and thus not subject to bodily resurrection as told through miracle stories. Likewise, our Universalist ancestors such as Ballou argued that Christians didn’t need substitutionary atonement --- they didn’t need someone dying so they might be saved --- because they believed that all humans are born into inherent goodness and thus eventual salvation.

But it hasn’t been just us rebellious Unitarians and Universalists who promoted heretical interpretations of Easter. As far back as the first decades after Jesus’ lifetime, a variety of interpretations of his life and death emerged. Many of these interpretations were recorded in the form of other ‘gospels’ that never made it to the ‘canon’ of the Bible as we know it today, because these stories didn’t support the establishment political system. The religion scholar Elaine Pagels has written several reader-friendly books about these early heretical movements. Pagels suggests that the controversies over the concept of ‘resurrection’ were the biggest factor in shaping the early Christian movement.

For example, today we know about a large collection of gospels known as the ‘Gnostic’ gospels (they were found in 1945 in Egypt) which offer a very different take on Jesus’s death and resurrection. The meaning of ‘Gnostic’ is ‘knowing’: that is, Gnostic Christians followed Jesus as source of inspiration to expand their own knowledge of the sacred. These Gnostic interpretations --- which Pagels tells about in The Gnostic Gospels --- give us a different view of the early years of the Christian movement and early understandings of ‘resurrection.’ Yes, these followers of Gnosticism affirmed the story of Jesus’ death by crucifixion on a cross, and, yes, they affirmed a process of ‘resurrection,’ but they understood resurrection not literally but metaphorically. For them, Jesus’s life and death provided a spiritual vision for how to become more holy, how to be in a process of growing into more knowledge about humans’ relation to the divine. Gnostics searched for the sparks of divinity that lie in each of us.

We modern Unitarian Universalists can identify with the early Gnostic Christians, because they were considered heretics just as our later Unitarian and Universalist ancestors were.

More Interpretations of Resurrection: Freedom from Bondage
But let’s go back to Rev. Sewell’s reading. She suggested yet other reasons for Easter. It is also a celebration of rebirth. In addition to those pagan celebrations recognizing the rebirth of the earth after a long, cold winter that we’ve already referred to, Rev. Sewell also suggested that humans celebrate Easter as a reminder that we do have the power to get out of bondage. Do you have a sense of what she means by ‘bondage?’--- things in our lives --- habits, beliefs, people, and more --- that lock us into ways of being that take us away from our authentic selves and cause us to experience various types of deaths --- loss of dreams, loss of plans, loss of good health. The miracle of the Easter story is that we each have the capacity to transform our lives --- to raise our lives from what sucks us downward --- and to promote goodness and love in this world. Easter, the holiday on the springtime calendar, stands as a reminder that personal re-birth is possible any time of the year.

Another writer who brings us thought-provoking ideas about this notion of rising from bondage is Rev. Dr. Rebecca Parker, currently president Starr King Theological School, the Unitarian Universalist seminary in Berkeley, California. She and a colleague, Rita Brock, wrote Proverbs of Ashes, a new theology of atonement based on their own personal experiences. It is a very touching book that I recommend to you.

As a young Methodist minister Rev. Parker heard many stories from within and outside her parish about physical and psychological abuse, including severe injury and killings. Most of these stories came from women, whose religions had taught them that suffering is noble and Christ-like, that they should not complain, but suck it up. (This reminds us of new allegations of sexual abuse in the Catholic church, allegations that have reached the news again in the past few weeks.) Parker herself had a personal experience of being forced to accept some hurts that caused her to live less than the full life she wanted to live. She began to question the theology she had grown up with, and one Lent she took her concerns to the pulpit, preaching a series of six sermons calling her congregation --- especially the women --- to break out of any cycles of violence and abuse. You can guess the strong reactions: some rejected her and threatened to leave her church, some wept and began to tell their stories, some left abusive relationships. Because this occurred around Easter time, there was a true experience of resurrection in her parish: a new way of finding love and getting in touch with what really saves us. Atonement for her congregants came through finding their own voices, their own search for the holy outside of the orthodox religious doctrine that had been keeping them in bondage. Parker herself found personal rebirth. She eventually became ordained in the Unitarian Universalist tradition. So many ways we can experience resurrection and rebirth.

Your Call
How do you relate to the many meanings of resurrection and how resurrection can help transform our lives? Are you in need of some resurrection, some rebirth, and might springtime be a good time to explore that rebirth?

Is you sense of resurrection grounded in nature? Do the emerging flowers, the budding trees, the newly-born animals in the field, inspire you to seek your own ventures into new avenues of life?

Do the stories of very human figures such as Jesus call you to your own spiritual deepening, on whatever path that deepening may take.

Are you living in any personal bondage that you would like to escape from? It is so easy to fall into personal tombs, to get caught up in life styles that keep us from connections to goodness and love and our authentic selves. We get caught up, addicted almost, in working too hard or worrying too much, we get caught up perhaps in addictions to substances like unhealthy food or drink or medications that take us away from ourselves, we become swayed by habits and principles that we don’t really believe in. There are many ways that bondage can remove us from ourselves and many way to experience resurrection.

At the end of our service today, our children will return and hand out Easter eggs that are filled not with sweets but with spiritual messages that may inspire your own rebirth.

Is there some resurrection, some rebirth, out there, awaiting your engagement? In your personal life, in your family or work life, in you place in this congregation, in your hopes for this country or for this fragile planet Earth? There are so many places waiting for rebirth. Today as we celebrate Easter with its many meanings, may we find resurrection and rebirth, and in so doing, bring hope to ourselves and those we love.

MAY THIS BE SO.

 

Please do not copy or reproduce without permission of the author.

 

Home | Labyrinth | Contact Us | Membership

 

Columbine Unitarian-Universalist Church
6724 South Webster Street
Littleton, Colorado 80128
303-972-1716