What Does a Healthy Congregation Look Like?
November 12, 2006

Reverend Barry Bloom

 

here is a story about a man who owned a large business. He felt responsible for the hundreds of lives that were dependent on the health of the business. He was a spirit driven man, that is one with an open heart, who really cared for his workers. One day he showed up in his office wearing a weird cap, one with two bills pointing in opposite directions. It looked funny. Several of his immediate staff filed into his office with puzzled smiles on their faces and asked him what in the world that cap was about. He answered by taking the hat off and showing them the writing on the front. It said, “I am their leader, which way did they go?”

Columbine has come a long way since its birth. Let me give you a brief history. In 1993, several families aided by assistance from First Universalist Church, held the first services. Soon the church moved to the “bunker”, a basement only building that was dark, but welcoming. Then, I’m unsure whether it was before or after the move to this building, Joel Miller was hired as the full time minister, with financial help from the UUA program that supports new churches. Then three extraordinary, frightening things happened that had a deep impact on the fabric of the church. The first was on April 20, 1999. An unprecedented killing of innocent students happened three blocks from here, at Columbine High School. Joel and many others helped in many ways, including supporting the students and families directly affected from the church. In an unrelated, yet profound incident, a year later two Columbine students were shot in cold blood during a robbery at the Subway store a block from here. And then, finally, we had our own experience of violence in the church itself, albeit emotional/ spiritual/ mental violence, not physical.

There were meetings of those distressed about our position as a welcoming congregation and how we should handle the meeting in our building of representatives of an organization that did not allow gays in their midst. The outcome was to ask the Boy Scouts, the offending organization, to leave as well as to put a sign up to declare our full support of gays, lesbians, bisexual, and transgendered people. The action and the sign met with mixed responses. The process, the violent part, was angry and blaming. Many of our best and brightest left in the midst of the recriminations that followed. It was uncomfortable for many. It was this congregation at its least healthy moment. Fear, misunderstanding, and angry conflict had taken over.

It is worth speculating about the role of the horrible violence nearby on the exaggerated, angry conflict that evolved inside this room. We are emotionally vulnerable to harm from such powerful darkness. We do not escape spiritual consequences just by saying, “all that is in the past, let it go.”

Over the five plus years since that time, much healing has happened. A number of those who left have returned and have stepped back into leadership positions again … for which we are deeply grateful. And, during my four plus years as your half time minister, I believe that healing has continued to work its wonder. Because of my background as a therapist and facilitator, I was a good match for you at the time that I was hired. The congregation needed nurturance and facilitation at that time. There was a large emotional/spiritual deficit that needed to be filled. That is where I concentrated my energies during my first 3 to 4 years as your minister.

Also, because I am a spiritually based person, one who believes in the leading and messages of the heart and soul as much as the logic and reason furnished by the brain, I brought spiritual leadership to you. To put it into the context of our tradition, I awoke the Universalist part of you.

But, and here is the good news, we are changing. Our needs are changing. What I do and have done is no longer enough. You have grown. You don’t need to have your corporate self esteem raised as much any more. You don’t need to just practice the spiritual, healing side of life any more. To paraphrase Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, you have grown out of the stage of needing to tend exclusively to your own journey, your own needs, and are ready to lift your vision to the surrounding world and tend to its needs, its hurts. You are ready to move from being what some have called a club to being a real live church. And you are doing your best to push me into leading you on to that new world. The message on the cap is in front of my eyes, “I am your leader. Which way did you go?” I’m coming. It will take my fastest sprint to get back to the head of the column again, but I’m a good runner!

Let me put this into other words.

For hundreds of years, the Unitarian and Universalist churches have provided leadership in the world around a number of profound social issues. The creation and support of the Underground Railroad to bring slaves out of the South into the free north. Women’s rights generally, and women’s suffrage in particular. (Remember, it has been well less than a hundred years since the 19th Amendment was ratified in Aug. of 1920).  The creation of a World Parliament of Religions. The Civil Rights Movement in the 1950’s and 60’s. And, more recently, the cause of equal rights for gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgendered folks. Plus our support for the environment and the great variety of movements and programs created over the years to assist the disenfranchised in our society. Those have been our causes, our work in the world, over these last 200 years or so.

But there is also the important INNER work, the transforming work inside of each person who is a UU, that is necessary for us to, in turn, transform that hurting world.

The state of our souls is equally important to the state of the world. In order to bring true healing energy to the world, i.e. before we can take effective social action, we must clean up our own house. We must work to be healthy, pro active individuals first, then we can join together and form a healthy church, or any other organization. Then we can act powerfully in the world. If we skip a step, we run the risk of acting from ego rather than spirit, from self seeking goals, rather than serving the human community. Let me say more.

Each of us, to me, is made up of body, mind, and spirit. And each of us is at a particular point on the continuum of health at any given moment ranging from very unhealthy to very healthy and every point in between. A practicing alcoholic on one end, a realized yogi on the other. You get the picture. Churches fit on a continuum of health as well.

At the low point of the crisis that I described earlier, we were on the far unhealthy end, a dysfunctional, painful place to be. Today we are somewhere in the middle, I would guess, somewhere on our journey to the far opposite end of radical health and well being. That is a big reason for the Long Range planning process that is taking place right now, asking us to declare “who are we, who do we want to be?”

Do we want to be forever small so that we can always know everybody and predict how we will behave? Or do we want to step outside our circle of safety and take risks in order to grow into a dynamic church that can help transform the community? The answer depends, in part, on our measure of health. Healthy individuals and healthy groups tend to take risks. Risk moving out of the familiar into the unknown. They are willing to take such risks because deep down in their souls they feel happy, loved, and safe in the world.

A large part of feeling such well being is related to the presence of spirit. If I know that I have been “loved since before the beginning,” I am ready to leap off high mountains. If I know deep in my soul that I am an integral part of this vast universe, that I am related to all living things on this earth as well, that we are all brothers and sisters, then I have an experience of being connected that nurtures me to my core. Which in turn gives me the perspective and confidence to act compassionately.

From that compassionate center, I, as an individual, am deeply prepared to reach out to others IN LOVE. A church community that lives from such a place is prepared to take transformative social action together til the cows come home.

Let’s move from my thoughts about healthy congregations to those of other Unitarian Universalists.

One of our most respected ministers who is also a writer is Tom Owen-Towle. He has recently written, “Growing a Beloved Community: Twelve Hallmarks of a Healthy Congregation.” A summary of those healthy characteristics include:

Occupy holy ground. A church is not a social club, but rather a place where people are called out of their daily routines for a sacred purpose.

Welcome all souls. Offer an open door to everyone, then lovingly attend to those who choose to stay.

Give EVERYONE a voice. Democracy requires the sharing of power.

Encourage unity amidst diversity … be diverse without becoming divided.

Balance justice and joy. Do good works but take time for fun as well.

Spread our good news … communicate our faith.

Practice respect and care of each other.

Nurture the stewards….the ones who keep the church spiritually, financially, and programmatically afloat.

Keep journeying ... resist the temptation to get too comfortable.

Another snapshot of a healthy congregation comes from programs found on the UUA web site. One of these, for small congregations in particular, has this quote:

“It is important to emphasize the difference in orientation from one of “church membership” to that of “personal ministry”:, from the consumer orientation where members expect the organization to deliver them spiritual care, to that of contributing one’s unique talents and gifts to others through a sense of personal ministry.”

One of Tom Owen-Towles’s hallmarks is to practice respect and care of each other. And that is the final point to which I would like to return. As I have often spoken, a fundamental measurement of the health of any group is how they communicate with, and about, each other. When communication is open and direct, when members are saying directly, kindly to someone with whom they are upset the nature of that upset, and the person receiving the communication is receptive, respectful, and non-defensive, we know all is well. When triangulation, pettiness, veiled criticism, and outright blame is our way of communicating, things are not working well. It is a prime measurement of our health and well being. As we Unitarian Universalists champion diversity, and insist everyone’s voice be heard, and that everyone’s beliefs and ideas have value, it is more incumbent on us than almost any other religious group to honor differences. The key to doing so is what I referred to earlier in this sermon. If I am operating in the world principally from ego, I may believe that what I have to say is right with a capital R and that what others have to contribute is not as important. From an ego center, I might spurn the needs of others or the community as a whole, in favor of my own needs. But if I am operating from spirit, from a place of openmindedness and love, I will see that I am a part of a whole, and that true strength evolves out of the unity of the gathered covenanted community. And I, and each of us, has a personal responsibility to continue to build that unity. As it is stated in our covenant:

“We will treat each other with respect, compassion, and kindness.

We will listen to and honor each other’s contributions.

We will acknowledge and address disagreements openly and gently, expressing our concerns directly with those involved.

We will accept responsibility for our part in making this spiritual community everything we want it to be.

We make these covenants with love in our hearts for each other and with a sincere desire to make the world around us better for our being here.”

There are many measurements of our health and well being right now, and few of our deficits. Our lay leadership is skilled and strong, we are in the middle of a well designed planning process, there are a number of small groups that are flourishing and contributing to a deeper quality of life for many, we have a strong, active committee on ministry, our worship services are satisfying, our religious education program is vital and growing, and so on. It is up to each one of us to continue the trend.

That is what I believe can happen from our recent ill fated congregational meeting. We are growing emotionally as a result of conflict. We are stretching. We are learning new perspectives. There is some pain, but what is the saying, no pain no gain. We gained a new energy and passion to get busy in the world. And, partially as a result of that gain, and a number of those other measurements of how we are doing, I pronounce us, Columbine Unitarian Universalist Church, as on the road to excellent health and well being. We have not arrived, we may never fully arrive, but we are on the journey.

Thus, may we take this time to sit in meditation … reflecting upon the question, “how can I best contribute to the health and well being of this church?"

Pastoral Prayer

 

Home | Labyrinth | Contact Us | Membership

 

Columbine Unitarian-Universalist Church
6724 South Webster Street
Littleton, Colorado 80128
303-972-1716